PROCEED
A clean verdict with no conditions. The deal is defensible across financial integrity, regulatory standing, market position, and deal structure. Even the downside scenario produces positive economics. The investor can close on the deal as structured.
About 30 percent of GCI verdicts are clean PROCEEDs. That does not mean the deal is without risk. It means the risk is identified, priced, and within the structure the investor can bear. A PROCEED verdict still comes with recommended diligence actions and a risk matrix; it just means no mandatory condition blocks closing.
Example: the Saudi logistics JV case study where the European partner received a PROCEED verdict because the downside case still produced positive EBITDA from year 2 and the SIDF covenant had 32 percent headroom.
PROCEED WITH CONDITIONS
The deal is viable only if specific conditions are satisfied before closing. The Conviction Report lists each condition explicitly with a responsible party and a deadline. If a condition cannot be met, the verdict says to restructure or pass.
About 45 percent of GCI verdicts are PROCEED WITH CONDITIONS. Typical conditions fall into four categories.
Written regulatory opinions. When a deal depends on a tax classification (VAT, QFZP, Zakat), foreign ownership rule, or licence timeline, GCI requires a written opinion from qualified counsel before capital commits.
Signed counterparty agreements. When the deal depends on a verbal operator exit, a handshake anchor tenant commitment, or an informal Saudi partner arrangement, GCI requires the agreement to be executed in writing before closing.
Independent verification of seller data. When seller-supplied occupancy, revenue, or operational metrics are material to valuation and cannot be cross-referenced from public sources, GCI requires audited verification.
Documented succession and governance. When the deal depends on continuity of a founder or key executive, GCI requires a signed employment and equity lock-in agreement with a minimum 24-month post-close commitment.
Example: the Al Reem Island aesthetic clinic received PROCEED WITH CONDITIONS subject to (1) signed lead physician letter of intent and (2) written VAT classification opinion.
AVOID
The deal should not close as structured. The Conviction Report lists the specific reasons. AVOID is a recommendation to preserve capital for a better opportunity.
About 25 percent of GCI verdicts are AVOID. Four patterns dominate.
Material regulatory or legal risk that cannot be mitigated. Foreign ownership breach, sanctioned counterparties, licence path blocked, or jurisdictional structure that traps repatriation.
Financial statements that do not reconcile. Tax filings, bank statements, and management accounts show materially different pictures. When the gap cannot be explained, the deal fails integrity.
Market position that does not survive stress testing. When the downside scenario produces a business that is capital-destructive rather than just lower-return, the investor should not commit.
Deal structure that traps the investor. Unbounded capital calls, subordinated positions without step-in rights, or exit structures that are unrecoverable under realistic scenarios.
The 5-stage pipeline that produces the verdict
Every verdict is produced through the same 5-stage GCI Conviction Engine.
- Assumption Extraction: identify every hidden assumption in the memo.
- Cross-Variable Synthesis: map how market, regulatory, and operational variables interact.
- Linkage Mapping: chain evidence and dependencies into a single reasoning spine.
- Contrarian Pressure Test: attack the thesis with its strongest counter-arguments.
- Evidence-Chain Report: every claim tied to one of five evidence tiers (VERIFIED, REPORTED, STATED, ESTIMATED, ASSUMED).
Three AI engines cross-check the analysis (Claude Opus 4.7 leads; GPT-4.1 and Gemini 2.5 Pro challenge). Disagreement between models is surfaced in the report, not hidden.
What verdicts are not
GCI verdicts are opinions formed under the documented methodology. They are not regulated investment advice. They are not a guarantee of outcomes. They are not a substitute for qualified legal, tax, and financial counsel in the relevant jurisdictions. Every allocator retains full responsibility for the investment decision.
Frequently asked questions
Can a verdict change after I receive it?
If material new information emerges within 30 days of report delivery, GCI will re-run the pipeline at 50 percent of the original fee. After 30 days, it is a new Conviction Report.
Do you ever deliver a split verdict (PROCEED for one aspect, AVOID for another)?
No. The value of the GCI verdict is that it collapses complexity into one clean answer. If different structural options produce different verdicts, we deliver one report per option. The client picks the structure.
How quickly can GCI deliver a Conviction Report?
Standard turnaround is 3 to 5 business days. Strategic Intelligence engagements deliver in 7 days. Express (same-day) is available at a premium on exceptional cases.
Get a verdict on your next deal
Order a Conviction Report from $499. Multi-engine cross-check. Evidence tiers on every claim. One verdict, delivered in 3 to 5 business days.